FOS decisions / Critical Illness Cover
Critical Illness Cover
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
20
Upheld
6
Not upheld
14
Avg redress
£756
Upheld complaints (6)
Zurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-5991267An insurer must not turn down claims unreasonably, and must fairly assess whether a policyholder has met the policy definition of total permanent disability based on their ability to perform the material and substantial duties of their own
UpheldNov 2025Zurich Assurance Limited
DRN-6032631An insurer must not unreasonably decline a critical illness claim, and cannot rely on a pre-existing risk exclusion unless it is fairly established that the policyholder was aware of an increased risk before cover commenced.
UpheldFeb 2025Legal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-5982215Insurers must handle claims promptly and fairly, and must communicate clearly with claimants about timescales and processes involved.
UpheldRedress £100The Royal London Mutual Insurance Society Limited
DRN-6012133An insurer must deal with a claim promptly and fairly and not unreasonably decline it, applying policy definitions that are clear and correctly communicated to the consumer.
UpheldUnum Ltd
DRN-6012783An insurer must deal with claims promptly and fairly, and not unreasonably decline them; the policy requires clear medical prognosis that disability will last throughout life with no prospect of improvement.
UpheldRedress £300Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-5944629An insurer must handle claims promptly and fairly, and should assess PTD claims based on the policyholder's ability to carry out their normal occupation as defined in the policy terms.
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (14)
Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-6225773An insurer is entitled to reasonably request additional information from third parties to validate a claim before determining liability, provided the policyholder has given appropriate authorization.
Not upheldDec 2025Legal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6182875A critical illness policy definition of 'irreversible' hearing loss requires that the condition cannot be reasonably improved by medical treatment or surgical procedures available on the NHS, not that it must be completely reversed.
Not upheldUnum Limited
DRN-6168167An insurer can decline a TPD claim where the claimant fails to provide specialist confirmation that their disability will last throughout life with no prospect of improvement whilst still covered under the policy.
Not upheldCanada Life Limited
DRN-6189411Pre-existing condition exclusions in group critical illness policies apply fairly when a condition existed (was diagnosed, treated, or known) prior to the date of policy inclusion, regardless of whether the claimant was aware of the full di
Not upheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-6190875A critical illness policy can only pay out when the policyholder meets one of the specified covered conditions listed in the policy terms.
Not upheldPhoenix Life CA Limited
DRN-6227541An insurer must not make material errors about policy terms and must provide fair compensation for service failures even where the underlying claim decision was correct.
Not upheldHL Partnership Limited
DRN-6215243A financial adviser must provide advice that balances suitable cover with the client's stated affordability constraints, and the suitability of that advice is assessed based on circumstances at the time of the sale, not with hindsight.
Not upheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6033733An insurer must assess claims fairly and promptly by reviewing medical evidence before determining liability, though it should aim to be clear about policy requirements from the outset.
Not upheldLiverpool Victoria Financial Services Limited
DRN-6225732Under CIDRA 2012, an insurer can apply proportionate remedies for careless misrepresentation if they would have offered the policy at different terms had the consumer disclosed all material facts.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6222284Under CIDRA 2012, a consumer must take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation when taking out insurance, and an insurer can refuse a claim if the misrepresentation is qualifying and the consumer failed to meet the reasonable care s
Not upheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6113868Under CIDRA 2012, an insurer may unwind a policy from inception if the consumer failed to take reasonable care when answering health questions, resulting in a qualifying misrepresentation.
Not upheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6190128A critical illness policy only pays out when the policyholder is diagnosed with a condition that meets the policy's definition; a misdiagnosis that is later corrected does not trigger a valid claim if the final confirmed diagnosis is not co
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6210507An insurer may cancel a policy following a discussion about overinsurance if the policyholder is given clear information about which policy is being cancelled and the option to seek independent advice.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6151591An insurer must assess claims according to the definition of total and permanent disability specified in the policy schedule, which cannot be changed or substituted after policy inception.
Not upheld